Examine the need for electoral reforms as suggested by various committees with particular reference to "one nation – one election" principle.
See the answer frameworkWhat to write, point by point
How to write this answer
- Examine Probe the issue in depth: Causes, evidence and consequences.
For Polity: Quote Articles, landmark cases and committees by name; end with a balanced way forward.
For this question: Give both sides of simultaneous elections, then name the Kovind committee and the 129th Amendment Bill.
Examine why electoral reforms are needed, as committees have recommended, with particular reference to 'one nation, one election' (simultaneous elections): The case for it, the case against, and what the reform requires.
Simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies were the norm from 1951‑52 to 1967. The cycle broke in 1968 and 1969 when some Assemblies were dissolved early, and today some election is held almost every year.
What committees have proposed
- The Law Commission's draft report of August 2018 favoured holding all direct elections within a single year and listed the amendments needed to the Constitution, the Representation of the People Act and the House rules.
- A high-level committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind, set up on 2 September 2023, recommended a framework for synchronised elections, with panchayat and municipal polls following the national and State polls.
- The Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024, was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 17 December 2024.
The case for simultaneous elections
- Cost: One round of polling costs less than repeated rounds and puts less strain on the administration and the security forces.
- Policy continuity: The model code of conduct would not freeze development work so often.
- Governance: Less time is spent on campaigning and more on governing.
Concerns
- Federalism: State issues may be drowned out by national ones, and early dissolution of an Assembly needs a workable rule.
- Amendments: Articles 83 and 172 and related provisions must be amended, and the States must ratify the changes for local-body polls (Article 324A) and a common electoral roll (Article 325).
- Logistics: Electronic voting machines, paper-trail (VVPAT) units and staff are needed for all elections at once.
Wider electoral reforms
- The Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) found money and muscle power and the criminalisation of politics to be the core problems of elections.
- The Law Commission's 170th Report proposed debarring candidates against whom a court has framed charges for certain offences, and disclosure of pending criminal cases.
- Other proposals concern the Election Commission's independence and the regulation of party finances.
Simultaneous elections could cut costs and policy paralysis, but only with careful safeguards for federalism and accountability. The reform should be judged on whether it strengthens the voter's choice.
Study the topic: One Nation One Election: Simultaneous Polls to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies · Election Commission of India: Article 324, Powers, Functions and Appointment
Sources: One Nation, One Election (Wikipedia)